Electoral Commission

Electoral Commission
(1877) Commission created to resolve the disputed 1876 presidential election between Republican Rutherford B. Hayes and Democrat Samuel Tilden.

Tilden had won the popular vote and was only one electoral vote short of victory, but the Republicans contested the tallies in four states, charging fraud. Unable to reach a consensus, Congress appointed a 15-member commission, evenly divided between the two parties, except for one justice, Joseph P. Bradley, a Republican considered nonpartisan; Republicans pressured him, and the tally went to Hayes, who was declared the winner on March 2. See also Wormley Conference.

* * *

United States [1877]
      (1877), in U.S. history, commission created by Congress to resolve the disputed presidential election of 1876 between Republican Rutherford B. Hayes (Hayes, Rutherford B.) and Democrat Samuel J. Tilden (Tilden, Samuel J). For the first time since before the Civil War the Democrats had polled a majority of the popular vote, and preliminary returns showed Tilden with 184 electoral votes of the 185 needed to win, while Hayes had 165. Three states were in doubt: Florida, Louisiana, and South Carolina, with 19 electoral votes among them. The status of one of Oregon's three electors—that had already been given to Tilden—was also in question. Hayes and most of his associates were ready to concede when a New Hampshire Republican leader, William E. Chandler, observed that if Hayes were awarded every one of the doubtful votes, he would defeat Tilden 185–184. Both parties claimed victory in all three Southern states and sent teams of observers and lawyers into all three in hopes of influencing the official canvass.

      The responsibility for resolving the conflicting claims rested with Congress—which was more evenly divided between the parties than it had been in decades. The U.S. Constitution provided that each state send its electoral certificate to the president of the Senate, who “shall, in the presence of the Senate and House of Representatives, open all the certificates, and the votes shall then be counted.” But it shed no light on whether Congress might, in a disputed election, go behind a state's certificate and review the acts of its certifying officials or even if it might examine the choice of electors. If it had such powers, might it delegate them to a commission?

      The impasse continued on December 6, the appointed date for electors to meet in the states. When Congress convened the next day there were rival reports from the doubtful states. For more than six weeks maneuvering and acrimony prevailed in Congress and out, punctuated by threats of civil war. Finally, Congress created an Electoral Commission (Jan. 29, 1877) to pass on the contests. The Commission was given “the same powers, if any,” possessed by Congress in the matter, and its decisions were to be final unless rejected by both houses.

      The Commission was to have five members from the House of Representatives, five from the Senate, and four members from the Supreme Court. Congressional and court contingents were divided evenly between Republicans and Democrats, and the four associate justices were to name a fifth, tacitly but universally understood to be the noted independent from Illinois, David Davis. At this stage the Republican-controlled legislature of Illinois elected Davis to the state's vacant U.S. Senate seat, and he refused the commission appointment, although he stayed on the Supreme Court until March 3. Thereupon the four justices picked their colleague Joseph P. Bradley (Bradley, Joseph P.), a Republican whose record made him acceptable to the Democrats.

      Bradley leaned toward Tilden's convincing claim to the Florida vote, the Commission's first action, but Republican pressures swayed him, and the Florida tally went to Hayes, who had almost certainly lost it in fact. Thenceforward all votes followed Florida, on a straight party-line 8–7 basis. (Hayes's claim to Oregon was clearly legitimate, and fraud and intimidation by both parties had been widespread in Louisiana and South Carolina.) The final vote was reported to Congress on February 23. After a week of ominous bluster, which Tilden did much to quiet among his aggrieved followers, a tumultuous session of Congress convened March 1 to count the electoral vote and after 4 AM the next day declared Hayes elected; he was sworn in on the following day. The verdict was received bitterly by Democrats in the North and philosophically by those in the South, who had been promised by Hayes's allies that federal troops would be removed promptly from the former Confederate states, as in fact they were before the end of April. The threats of violence that had recurred throughout the dispute came to naught, giving a welcome sense of assurance to both factions that, even so soon after the Civil War, self-government and domestic peace were not incompatible.

* * *


Universalium. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Electoral Commission — Electoral Commission, a board of commissioners created in 1877 by act of Congress to decide the validity of certain electoral votes following the election of 1876. Its decisions resulted in the election of Rutherford B. Hayes to the Presidency …   Useful english dictionary

  • Electoral Commission — An Electoral Commission or Election Commission is an election management body, in charge of overseeing the implementation of election procedures: Albania: Komisioni Qendror i Zgjedhjeve Australia: Australian Electoral Commission New South Wales… …   Wikipedia

  • Electoral Commission —    The Electoral Commission was created by the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. It is responsible for: advising the Government on the reform of electoral law; working with the Boundary Committee in determining the boundary… …   Glossary of UK Government and Politics

  • Electoral Commission (United States) — The Electoral Commission was a temporary body created by Congress to resolve the disputed United States presidential election of 1876. It consisted of 15 members. The election was contested by the Democratic ticket, Samuel J. Tilden and Thomas A …   Wikipedia

  • Electoral Commission (New Zealand) — The Electoral Commission of New Zealand is a governmental body responsible for administering certain aspects of the country s electoral system. It is an independent Crown entity, not part of any larger department or Ministry, and was established… …   Wikipedia

  • Electoral Commission (United Kingdom) — The Electoral Commission is a non departmental public body with powers in the United Kingdom, which was created by an Act of Parliament, the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 (2000 c. 41). In 2002 the Boundary Committee for… …   Wikipedia

  • Independent National Electoral Commission — The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), set up in 1998, is the electoral body which was set up to oversee elections in Nigeria.[1] The INEC has encountered several controversies in the run up to the April 2007 general elections,… …   Wikipedia

  • Victorian Electoral Commission — Infobox Government agency agency name = Victorian Electoral Commission logo = logo width = logo caption = formed = preceding1 = State Electoral Office dissolved = superseding = jurisdiction = Government of Victoria employees = chief1 name = Mr… …   Wikipedia

  • Zimbabwe Electoral Commission — (ZEC) is a nominally independent organization which controls elections at all levels of Zimbabwe politics. It was established by an Act of the Parliament in 2004, with influence from its predecessor, the Electoral Supervisory Commission as well… …   Wikipedia

  • Australian Electoral Commission — The Australian Electoral Commission, or the AEC, is the federal government agency in charge of organising and supervising federal elections and referendums. State and local government elections are overseen by the Electoral Commission in each… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”