Garfield, James A.

▪ president of United States

in full  James Abram Garfield 

born November 19, 1831, near Orange [in Cuyahoga county], Ohio, U.S.

died September 19, 1881, Elberon [now in Long Branch], New Jersey

 20th president of the United States (March 4–September 19, 1881), who had the second shortest tenure in presidential history. When he was shot and incapacitated, serious constitutional questions arose concerning who should properly perform the functions of the presidency. (For a discussion of the history and nature of the presidency, see presidency of the United States of America.)

      Garfield was the son of Abram Garfield and Eliza Ballou, who continued to run the family's impoverished Ohio farm after her husband's death in 1833. The last president born in a log cabin, Garfield dreamed of foreign ports of call as a sailor but instead worked for a time on a boat on the Ohio Canal between Cleveland, Ohio, and Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Always studious, he attended Western Reserve Eclectic Institute (later Hiram College) at Hiram, Ohio, and graduated (1856) from Williams College. He returned to the Eclectic Institute as a professor of ancient languages and in 1857, at age 25, became the school's president. A year later he married Lucretia Rudolph (Lucretia Garfield (Garfield, Lucretia)) and began a family that included seven children (two died in infancy). Garfield also studied law and was ordained as a minister in the Disciples of Christ church, but he soon turned to politics.

      An advocate of free-soil principles (opposing the extension of slavery), he became a supporter of the newly organized Republican Party and in 1859 was elected to the Ohio legislature. During the Civil War he helped recruit the 42nd Ohio Volunteer Infantry and became its colonel. After commanding a brigade at the Battle of Shiloh (Shiloh, Battle of) (April 1862), he was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives, and while waiting for Congress to begin its session, he served as chief of staff in the Army of the Cumberland, winning promotion to major general after distinguishing himself at the Battle of Chickamauga (Chickamauga Creek, Battle of) (September 1863). It was about that time that Garfield had an extramarital affair with a Lucia Calhoun in New York City. He later admitted the indiscretion and was forgiven by his wife. Historians believe that the many letters he had written to Calhoun, which are referred to in his diary, were retrieved by Garfield and destroyed.

      For nine terms, until 1880, Garfield represented Ohio's 19th congressional district. As chairman of the House Committee on Appropriations, he became an expert on fiscal matters and advocated a high protective tariff; as a Radical Republican, he sought a firm policy of Reconstruction for the South. In 1880 the Ohio legislature elected him to the U.S. Senate.

 At the Republican presidential convention the same year in Chicago, the delegates were divided into three principal camps: the “Stalwarts” (Stalwart) (conservatives led by powerful New York Senator Roscoe Conkling (Conkling, Roscoe)), who backed former president Ulysses S. Grant (Grant, Ulysses S.), the “Half-Breed” (moderate) supporters of Maine Senator James G. Blaine (Blaine, James G.), and those committed to Secretary of the Treasury John Sherman (Sherman, John). Tall, bearded, affable, and eloquent, Garfield steered fellow Ohioan Sherman's campaign and impressed so many with his nominating speech that he, not the candidate, became the focus of attention. As the chairman of the Ohio delegation, Garfield also led a coalition of anti-Grant delegates who succeeded in rescinding the unit rule, by which a majority of delegates from a state could cast the state's entire vote. This victory added to Garfield's prominence and doomed Grant's candidacy. Grant led all other candidates for 35 ballots, but failed to command a majority; and on the 36th ballot the nomination went to a dark horse, Garfield, who was still trying to remove his name from nomination as the bandwagon gathered speed.

  Cabinet of President James A. GarfieldHis Democratic opponent in November was General Winfield Scott Hancock (Hancock, Winfield Scott), like Garfield a Civil War veteran, so both could wrap themselves in the symbolic “bloody shirt” of the Union. But Garfield also capitalized on his rags-to-riches background, and along with a campaign biography literally written by Horatio Alger (Alger, Horatio), he reached back to his humble beginnings as a “canal boy” for the slogan “From the tow path to the White House.” (“No man ever started so low that accomplished so much, in all our history,” said former president Rutherford B. Hayes (Hayes, Rutherford B.) of Garfield. He was “the ideal self-made man.”) In an era when it was still considered unseemly for a candidate to court voters actively, Garfield, aided by Lucretia (who remained an important adviser), conducted the first “front porch” campaign, from his home in Mentor, Ohio, where reporters and voters came to hear him speak. Notwithstanding allegations of involvement in the Crédit Mobilier Scandal, in which Garfield had received $329 from stock in the notorious company (a remuneration which Democrats characterized as a bribe and played up as a campaign issue by plastering walls, sidewalks, and placards with “329”), and a forged letter that supposedly revealed Garfield's advocacy of unrestricted Chinese immigration, he defeated Hancock (as well as the third-party Greenback (Greenback movement) candidate), though he won the popular election by fewer than 10,000 votes. The vote in the electoral college was less close: 214 votes for Garfield, 155 for Hancock. (The table provides a list of cabinet members in the administration of President James A. Garfield. Cabinet of President James A. Garfield)

 By the time of his election, Garfield had begun to see education rather than the ballot box as the best hope for improving the lives of African Americans. In his inaugural speech he said, “The elevation of the Negro race from slavery to the full rights of citizenship is the most important political change we have known since the adoption of the Constitution of 1787. No thoughtful man can fail to appreciate its beneficent effect upon our institutions and people.…It has liberated the master as well as the slave from a relation which wronged and enfeebled both.” (See primary source document: Inaugural Address (James A. Garfield: Inaugural Address).)

      Garfield tried to put together a cabinet that would appease all factions of the Republican Party, but, prompted by his secretary of state, Blaine, he eventually challenged Conkling (Conkling, Roscoe)'s patronage (spoils system) machine in New York. Instead of appointing one of Conkling's friends as collector of the Port of New York, Garfield chose a Blaine protégé, prompting the resignation of an outraged Conkling and strengthening the independence and power of the presidency. So demanding were the office seekers and the pressures of the patronage system that at one point Garfield wondered why anyone would want to seek the presidency. “My God,” he exclaimed, “what is there in this place that a man should ever want to get into it!” The other significant development of Garfield's short term of office, the Star Route Scandal, involved the fraudulent dispersal of postal route contracts. “Go ahead regardless of where or whom you hit,” Garfield told investigators. “I direct you not only to probe this ulcer to the bottom, but to cut it out.” Despite such strong talk, Grant accused Garfield of having “the backbone of an angleworm.”

 On July 2, 1881, after only four months in office, while on his way to visit his ill wife in Elberon, New Jersey, Garfield was shot in the back at the railroad station in Washington, D.C., by Charles J. Guiteau, a disappointed office seeker with messianic visions. Guiteau peaceably surrendered to police, calmly announcing, “I am a Stalwart. [Chester A.] Arthur is now president of the United States.” For 80 days the president lay ill and performed only one official act—the signing of an extradition paper. It was generally agreed that, in such cases, the vice president (vice president of the United States of America) was empowered by the Constitution to assume the powers and duties of the office of president. But should he serve merely as acting president until Garfield recovered, or would he receive the office itself and thus displace his predecessor? Because of an ambiguity in the Constitution, opinion was divided, and, because Congress was not in session, the problem could not be debated there. On September 2, 1881, the matter came before a cabinet meeting, where it was finally agreed that no action would be taken without first consulting Garfield. But in the opinion of the doctors this was impossible, and no further action was taken before the death of the president, the result of slow blood poisoning, on September 19.

      The public and the media were obsessed with this drawn-out passing of the president, leading historians to see in the brief Garfield administration the seeds of an important aspect of the modern president: the chief executive as celebrity and symbol of the nation. It is said that public mourning for Garfield was more extravagant than the grief displayed in the wake of President Abraham Lincoln's assassination, which is startling in light of the relative roles these men played in American history. Garfield was buried beneath a quarter-million-dollar, 165-foot (50-metre) monument in Lake View Cemetery in Cleveland.

Additional Reading

A collection of papers by Garfield is found in Burke A. Hinsdale (ed.), The Works of James Abram Garfield, 2 vol. (1882–83, reprinted 1970). Harry James Brown and Frederick D. Williams (eds.), The Diary of James A. Garfield, 4 vol. (1967–81), provides much information about his life and times from 1848, when he was 16, to 1881, the year of his death. Theodore Clarke Smith, The Life and Letters of James Abram Garfield, 2 vol. (1925, reprinted 1968), is also of interest. Biographical works include John M. Taylor, Garfield of Ohio: The Available Man (1970), tracing Garfield's life and career until his assassination; Margaret Leech and Harry J. Brown, The Garfield Orbit (1978), with greater focus on Garfield the man than the politician; Allan Peskin, Garfield (1978, reprinted 1987); and Hendrik Booraem V, The Road to Respectability: James A. Garfield and His World, 1844–1852 (1988), which examines Garfield's youth. His political life is discussed in Robert Granville Caldwell, James A. Garfield, Party Chieftain (1931, reissued 1965); and Justus D. Doenecke, The Presidencies of James A. Garfield & Chester A. Arthur (1981). The personality of Garfield's wife, Lucretia Rudolph Garfield, is revealed in John Shaw (ed.), Crete and James: Personal Letters of Lucretia and James Garfield (1994).

* * *