ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH: Conflict in Orthodoxy

ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH: Conflict in Orthodoxy
▪ 1997

      The most serious threat of schism in centuries occurred in Eastern Orthodoxy in February 1996 when Bartholomew I, ecumenical patriarch of Constantinople, decreed that the Estonian Orthodox Apostolic Church was autonomous under his authority rather than under the authority of the Russian Orthodox Church. Aleksey II, patriarch of Russia, responded by formally "suspending communion" between the Russian church and Constantinople. The conflict arose in the wake of two years of failed negotiations regarding the patriarchate to which the Estonian church was subject. The church was under the Moscow patriarchate until 1923, when Soviet interests in Estonia threatened it and a special diocese was created by Constantinople to offer spiritual protection to its members. In 1945, soon after Estonia was annexed by the Soviet Union again, all Orthodox communities in Estonia were reconstituted as a diocese under the Moscow Patriarchate. In 1947 Estonian Orthodox Christians in exile in Stockholm successfully sought the official protection of Constantinople.

      At stake in Estonia was jurisdiction over 54 clerics and 60,000 members of the Orthodox Church. Some estimated that as much as 5% of Estonian land was Orthodox Church property. Most of the prominent Orthodox leaders throughout the world publicly took sides in the conflict. The Estonian government and the Orthodox Church in Finland supported Bartholomew. Dissident and controversial leaders in Ukraine and Russia, such as the disputed head of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, supported him as well.

      Aleksey's position appeared to be in the best interests of the Russian government and the Russian church. He was supported by leaders of the Orthodox churches in Antioch, Jerusalem, Serbia, Bulgaria, and Poland. Nevertheless, his aggressive defense of ethnic Russians and historic Russian interests in surrounding countries caused concern that a traditionalist, nationalist Slavic orthodoxy might become dominant.

      In May the ecumenical patriarchate announced that in order to maintain Orthodox unity, each Estonian Orthodox parish would be allowed to choose to which ecclesiastical head it would relate. The Moscow patriarchate responded by restoring full communion with the ecumenical patriarchate. This solution, however, was likely to repeat the pattern of conflict in Orthodoxy in the U.S., where individual congregations had battled over preferred patriarchates, creating many congregations with ties to various overseas bodies.

      Globally, the potential schism marked an increasing uneasiness over the role of Constantinople in guiding Eastern Orthodoxy's 250 million members worldwide. Though Bartholomew was considered "first among equals" among Orthodox patriarchs, there was growing concern over Constantinople's intervention in Estonia, Ukraine, and Japan, as well as the patriarch's training under the Pontifical Oriental Institute in Rome and his strong opposition to SCOBA, the pan-Orthodox synod of bishops in North America. Also at stake were the emerging dialogues with the Roman Catholic, Oriental Orthodox, and other Christian bodies. (TODD M. JOHNSON)

* * *


Universalium. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Timeline of the Roman Catholic Church — As one the oldest branches of Christianity, with Eastern Orthodoxy, [The Eastern Orthodox and some other churches are also apostolic in origin i.e., they also date their origins back to the founding of the Christian Church at the time of the… …   Wikipedia

  • Catholic Church — This article is about the church in communion with the See of Rome. For other uses, see Catholic Church (disambiguation). Roman Christianity redirects here. For other uses, see Roman Christianity (disambiguation). Part of a series on the Catholic …   Wikipedia

  • Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Lyon — The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Lyon is a Roman Catholic Metropolitan archdiocese in France. It incorporates the ancient Archdiocese of Vienne. The current Cardinal Archbishop is Philippe Barbarin. He is the successor of Saint Pothinus and… …   Wikipedia

  • Roman Catholicism — the faith, practice, and system of government of the Roman Catholic Church. [1815 25] * * * Largest single Christian denomination in the world, with some one billion members, or about 18% of the world s population. The Roman Catholic church has… …   Universalium

  • church year — ▪ Christianity Introduction       annual cycle of seasons and days observed in the Christian churches in commemoration of the life, death, and Resurrection of Jesus Christ and of his virtues as exhibited in the lives of the saints. Origins of the …   Universalium

  • CHURCH, CATHOLIC — Under the Roman Empire While a Catholic (i.e., universal ) Church came into being only at the Council of Nicaea in 325, a unified interpretation of the new religion of christianity had begun to emerge during the three preceding centuries, and… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Church Fathers — The Church Fathers, an 11th century Kievan miniature from Svyatoslav s Miscellany The Church Fathers, Early Church Fathers, Christian Fathers, or Fathers of the Church were early and influential theologians, eminent Christian teachers and great… …   Wikipedia

  • Roman Catholicism in China — See also: Christianity in China Roman Catholicism in China (called Tiānzhǔ jiào, 天主教, literally, Religion of the Lord of Heaven , after the term for God traditionally used in Chinese by Catholics) has a long and complicated history. Christianity… …   Wikipedia

  • Church of the East — For other uses, see Church of the East (disambiguation). Nestorian Church redirects here. For other uses, see Nestorian (disambiguation). Nestorian priests in a procession on Palm Sunday, in a 7th or 8th century wall painting from a Nestorian… …   Wikipedia

  • History of the Eastern Orthodox Church — The Eastern Orthodox Churches trace their roots back to the Apostles and Jesus Christ. Eastern Orthodoxy reached its golden age during the high point of the Byzantine Empire, and then continued to flourish in Russia after the Fall of… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”