- medical jurisprudence
n.the application of medical knowledge to questions of law affecting life or property, including ascertaining and certifying the cause of death, proper medical practice, etc.
* * *or legal medicineScience of applying medical facts to legal problems.Routine tasks include filling out birth and death certificates, deciding insurance eligibility, and reporting infectious disease. Perhaps more significant is medical testimony in court. When merely relating observations, doctors are ordinary witnesses; interpreting facts based on medical knowledge makes them expert witnesses, required to present their opinions without bias toward the side that called them. Conflicts between medicine and law can occur, usually over medical confidentiality. See also forensic medicine.
* * *also called Legal Medicine,science that deals with the relation and application of medical facts to legal problems. Medical persons giving legal evidence may appear before courts of law, administrative tribunals, inquests, licensing agencies, boards of inquiry or certification, or other investigative bodies.Doctors in most countries are legally obligated to certify persons for workers' compensation or other national insurance plans, to certify the occurrence of a birth or the cause of a death, to notify the authorities of any cases of specified infectious diseases, and to determine when mentally disturbed persons need to be detained to protect themselves or others. These routine acts constitute the most frequent tasks of medical jurisprudence.Less frequent but perhaps more significant are the uses of the doctor as a witness. When doctors appear in court merely to relate facts that they have observed, they are governed by the rules applicable to an ordinary witness. If they have to interpret those facts with their medical knowledge, they are known as “expert” witnesses and are expected to present their opinions fairly and without bias toward the litigant by whom they have been called. Despite this expectation, conflicts of medical opinion in court are common, perhaps because the human body and its ailments are less controlled by rule than is the law.Medicine and the law (legal ethics) do not always work in harmony. The most common source of conflict is medical confidentiality. Some doctors claim that any information received from a patient during a medical consultation is subject ethically to absolute confidentiality and can in no circumstances be revealed without the patient's permission. Without such a rule, they believe, patients sometimes would not give doctors all the information needed to treat them. Other doctors (a majority in most countries) believe that occasionally, though very rarely, their obligations to society override their obligations to their patients. Many, but not all, would report to the police a patient with severe epilepsy who, despite a warning from them, persisted in driving a car. This conflict with the law arises because, in most countries, courts, while recognizing legal privilege (the confidentiality of exchanges between lawyers and their clients), do not extend the same recognition to medical consultants. Other conflicts with legal systems arise because doctors have recognized that their responsibility to their patient takes precedence over all others. National and international medical associations have, for instance, advised doctors in countries where torture is legal that they must not be party to it by performing medical examinations to ensure that a prisoner is fit to be tortured. They have also warned doctors against being involved in any police procedure where, without their patient's consent, they could be asked to do something not in their patient's interest.Law and medicine come together more harmoniously in forensic medicine, a medical specialty that assists in the detection of crime. Specialists in forensic medicine also assist courts—including the coroner's court in Anglo-Saxon law—to determine the cause of sudden and unexpected deaths. In these cases the main investigation that a forensic specialist employs is a postmortem examination of the body, involving a careful examination of every organ and its contents, with sections of some organs being studied microscopically and subjected to chemical and DNA tests. Forensic medicine encompasses dramatic activities like determining the size and sex of a body by examining just a few bones, identifying a corpse from its dental pattern, or detecting evidence of rape or of unsuspected murder. It more commonly involves estimating the time of a person's death or measuring alcohol level in the blood of a motorist and thus establishing the degree of impaired judgment.
* * *