Patel, Vallabhbhai Jhaverbhai

▪ Indian statesman

Introduction

byname  Sardār Patel (Hindi: “Leader Patel”)  

born Oct. 31, 1875, Nadiād, Gujarāt, India

died Dec. 15, 1950, Bombay

      Indian barrister and statesman, one of the leaders of the Indian National Congress during the struggle for Indian independence. During the first three years of Indian independence after 1947, he served as deputy prime minister, minister of home affairs, minister of information, and minister of states.

Early life

      Patel was born into a self-sufficient landowning family of the Leva Patidar caste. Reared in an atmosphere of traditional Hinduism, he attended primary school at Karamasad and high school at Petlād but was mainly self-taught. Patel married at the age of 16, matriculated at 22, and passed the district pleader's examination, which enabled him to practice law. In 1900 he set up an independent office of district pleader in Godhra, and two years later he moved to Borsad, in Kheda district.

Legal career

      As a lawyer, Patel distinguished himself in presenting an unassailable case in a precise manner and in challenging police witnesses and British judges. In 1908 Patel lost his wife, who had borne him a son and daughter, and thereafter remained a widower. Determined to enhance his career in the legal profession, Patel traveled to London in August 1910 to study at the Middle Temple. There he studied diligently and passed the final examinations with high honours.

      Returning to India in February 1913, he settled in Ahmadābād, rising rapidly to become the leading barrister in criminal law at the Ahmadābād bar. Reserved and courteous, he was noted for his superior mannerisms, his smart, English-style clothes, and his championship in bridge at Ahmadābād's fashionable Gujarāt Club. He was, until 1917, indifferent to Indian political activities.

      In 1917 Patel found the course of his life changed after having been influenced by Mohandas K. Gandhi (Gandhi, Mohandas Karamchand). Patel adhered to Gandhi's satyagraha (policy of nonviolence) insofar as it furthered the Indian struggle against the British. But he did not identify himself with Gandhi's moral convictions and ideals, and he regarded Gandhi's emphasis on their universal application as irrelevant to India's immediate political, economic, and social problems. Nevertheless, having resolved to follow and support Gandhi, Patel changed his style and appearance. He quit the Gujarāt Club, dressed in the white cloth of the Indian peasant, and ate in the Indian manner.

      From 1917 to 1924 Patel served as the first Indian municipal commissioner of Ahmadābād and was its elected municipal president from 1924 to 1928. Patel first made his mark in 1918, when he planned mass campaigns of peasants, farmers, and landowners of Kaira district, Gujarāt, against the decision of the Bombay government to collect the full annual revenue taxes despite crop failures caused by heavy rains.

      In 1928 Patel successfully led the landowners of Bārdoli in their resistance against increased taxes. His efficient leadership of the Bārdoli campaign earned him the title sardār (“leader”), and henceforth he was acknowledged as a nationalist leader throughout India. He was considered practical, decisive, and even ruthless, and the British recognized him as a dangerous enemy.

Political philosophy.

      Patel, however, was no revolutionary. In the crucial debate over the objectives of the Indian National Congress during the years 1928 to 1931, Patel believed (like Gandhi and Motilal Nehru, but unlike Jawaharlal Nehru (Nehru, Jawaharlal) and Subhas Chandra Bose) that the goal of the Indian National Congress should be dominion status within the British Commonwealth—not independence. In contrast to Jawaharlal Nehru, who condoned violence in the struggle for independence, Patel ruled out armed revolution, not on moral but on practical grounds. Patel held that it would be abortive and would entail severe repression. Patel, like Gandhi, saw advantages in the future participation of a free India in a British Commonwealth, provided that India was admitted as an equal member. He emphasized the need to foster Indian self-reliance and self-confidence, but, unlike Gandhi, he did not regard Hindu-Muslim unity as a prerequisite for independence.

      Patel disagreed with Jawaharlal Nehru on the need to bring about economic and social changes by coercion. A conservative rooted in traditional Hindu values, Patel belittled the usefulness of adapting socialist ideas to the Indian social and economic structure. He believed in free enterprise, thus gaining the trust of conservative elements, and thereby collected the funds that sustained the activities of the Indian National Congress.

      Patel was the second candidate after Gandhi to the presidency of the 1929 Lahore session of the Indian National Congress. Gandhi shunned the presidency in an attempt to prevent the adoption of the resolution of independence and exerted pressure on Patel to withdraw, mainly owing to Patel's uncompromising attitude toward the Muslims; Jawaharlal Nehru was elected. During the 1930 Salt Satyāgraha, (prayer and fasting movement), Patel served three months' imprisonment. In March 1931 Patel presided over the Karāchi session of the Indian National Congress. He was imprisoned in January 1932. Released in July 1934, he marshaled the organization of the Congress Party in the 1937 elections and was the main contender for the 1937–38 Congress presidency. Again, because of Gandhi's pressure, Patel withdrew and Jawaharlal Nehru was elected. Along with other Congress leaders, Patel was imprisoned in October 1940, released in August 1941, and imprisoned once more from August 1942 until June 1945.

      During the war Patel rejected as impractical Gandhi's nonviolence in the face of the then-expected Japanese invasion of India. On the transfer of power, Patel differed with Gandhi in realizing that the partition of the subcontinent into Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan was inevitable, and he asserted that it was in India's interests to part with Pakistan.

      Patel was the leading candidate for the 1945–46 presidency of the Indian National Congress, but Gandhi once again intervened for the election of Nehru. Nehru, as president of the Congress, was invited by the British viceroy to form an interim government. Thus, in the normal course of events, Patel would have been the first prime minister of India. During the first three years of independence, Patel was deputy prime minister, minister of home affairs, minister of information, and minister of states; above all, his enduring fame rests on his achievement of the peaceful integration of the princely Indian states into the Indian Union and the political unification of India.

Daniel Argov

Additional Reading

D.V. Tahmankar, Sardar Patel (1970), is an important biography. Michael Brecher, Nehru: A Political Biography (1959), includes the best analysis of the confrontation between Nehru and Patel. V.P. Menon, The Story of the Integration of the Indian States (1956, reprinted as Integration of the Indian States, 1985), highlights the role of Patel.

* * *